Archive · 18 Nov 2025
Karnataka's Rs 613 Crore Sweeper Machine Deal Sparks Outrage and Allegations of Financial Scam
The Karnataka government wants to rent special cleaning machines for the roads in Bengaluru for seven years.
They approved a deal costing over 613 crore rupees for 46 machines.
Some people, like a government minister and others online, are very upset about this.
They say that buying these machines should cost much, much less, maybe only around 100 crore rupees in total, even with drivers and upkeep.
They think the government is spending way too much money and might be hiding something or wasting public funds.
The government says renting is better than buying right now because buying them all at once would cost a lot of money upfront.
They also mention that the machines will help clean the city's roads.
But the critics are still asking where all that extra money is going and want the deal to be stopped and looked at more closely.
Karnataka government approved renting 46 mechanical road sweeping machines for seven years at a cost of ₹613.25 crore.
Critics allege a massive financial scam due to the inflated rental cost, with estimates suggesting the actual cost should not exceed ₹100 crore.
Opposition leaders and netizens question the transparency and accountability of the deal, with calls for dropping the proposal and ensuring transparency.
The government defends the decision, citing advice from consulting firms and the high initial outlay required for outright purchase.
Concerns have also been raised about the existence of 26 unused sweeping machines in Bengaluru's BBMP yards and questions about the overall procurement process.
- Who
- Karnataka's Congress government, Union Minister Shobha Karandlaje, JD(S) leader Nikhil Kumar, netizens, consulting firms (BCG, RITES), and the public.
- What
- Controversy over the Karnataka government's approval to rent 46 mechanical road sweeping machines for seven years at a cost of ₹613.25 crore, with allegations of a major financial scam.
- When
- The government authorized the rental on November 13th; criticism emerged around November 14th-17th.
- Where
- Karnataka, specifically within the Greater Bengaluru Authority's (GBA) boundaries.
- Why
- Critics allege the rental cost is inflated, suggesting a financial scam, while the government cites reasons of high initial purchase costs and the need for efficient road cleaning.
Opposition & Critics
Karnataka Government & Supporters
Rental Cost Justification
Opposition & Critics
The Rs 613 crore rental cost for 46 machines over seven years is excessively high, with estimates suggesting the actual cost should not exceed Rs 100 crore, indicating a potential scam and misuse of funds.
Karnataka Government & Supporters
The cost per machine is approximately Rs 2 crore annually, and the decision to rent was based on advice from consulting firms like BCG, which suggested it was more financially viable than outright purchase due to high initial outlay.
Procurement Method
Opposition & Critics
The government should have considered purchasing the machines outright, especially since similar machines are available for purchase at much lower prices (Rs 1.3-3 crore or Rs 50-80 lakh), and there are existing unused machines.
Karnataka Government & Supporters
Renting was deemed more practical due to the 'huge initial expenditure' required for purchasing, with a proposed payment model involving an advance and performance-based reimbursement.
Transparency and Accountability
Opposition & Critics
There are serious doubts about where the remaining Rs 500 crore is going, and concerns are raised about who is benefiting from the inflated expenditure, with calls for dropping the proposal and ensuring transparency.
Karnataka Government & Supporters
The funding for the rental agreement would come from the five newly created municipal corporations of Bengaluru.
- Total Rental Cost Approved
- ₹613.25 crore
- Number of Machines
- 46
- Rental Period
- 7 years
- Location of Operation
- Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA) boundaries
- Estimated Annual Cost Per Machine
- Approx. ₹2 crore
- Estimated Purchase Cost Per Machine
- ₹50 lakh to ₹80 lakh (according to Karandlaje), ₹1.3-3 crore (according to Nikhil Kumar), ₹40-50 lakh (experts)
- Funding Source
- Five newly created municipal corporations of Bengaluru