8 months ago

Bengal SIR Hearings Spark Controversy

Bengal SIR Hearings Spark Controversy
EC summons TMC MP Dev, family for SIR review; party cries harassment of actor-MP - Telegraph India · telegraphindia.com

In West Bengal, a process called Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is happening to check and update the voter list.

This process has caused a lot of trouble for elderly, disabled, and daily wage earners.

Many of them have to travel long distances, lose their wages, and face physical distress just to prove they are legitimate voters.

Some people, like an 87-year-old woman and a man with 80% disability, had to go through a lot of hardship.

The ruling party says this process might stop genuine voters from voting, while the opposition party says it's necessary for a clean voter list.

The Election Commission has also asked some famous people, like actor Deepak Adhikari and cricketer Mohammad Shami, to prove their citizenship.

The Chief Minister, Mamata Banerjee, has criticized the process and plans to go to court against it.

The Election Commission and the BJP say the process is routine and necessary for accurate voter lists.

Key facts

Draft Electorate
7.08 crore
Names Deleted
58 lakh
Electors Under Scrutiny
1.67 crore
Logical Discrepancies
1.36 crore
Missing Mapping Records
31 lakh
Summoned MP
Deepak Adhikari (Dev)
Summoned Cricketer
Mohammad Shami
Summoned Poet
Joy Goswami
Summoned Actor Couple
Kaushik Banerjee and Laboni Sarkar
Summoned Actor
Anirban Bhattacharya

Timeline

  1. Election Commission trials voter list update in Bihar.

  2. Then, it expands nationwide, following success.

  3. Revision announced, sparking political debate.

  4. Process causes voter inconvenience.

Quotes

Navdeep Rinwa

Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) of Uttar Pradesh

“These lists can be found online on ceouttarpradesh.nic.in, or voters.eci.gov.in websites under the ASDDR list (A-‘Absent’, S ‘Shifted’, D ‘Dead’, D ‘Duplicate’ and R as ‘Enumeration Form Refused’).”
indianexpress.com
“The 2.89 crore names are those whom Booth Level Officers (BLOs) could not locate or whose enumeration forms they didn’t receive.”
indianexpress.com

Derek O'Brien's application

An application filed by Trinamool Congress MP Derek O'Brien in the Supreme Court

“The ECI cannot act arbitrarily, capriciously or dehors law, nor can it substitute legally prescribed and set procedures with ad hoc or informal mechanisms.”
m.rediff.com

Sources

Related news