8 months ago
Bengal SIR Hearings Spark Controversy
In West Bengal, a process called Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is happening to check and update the voter list.
This process has caused a lot of trouble for elderly, disabled, and daily wage earners.
Many of them have to travel long distances, lose their wages, and face physical distress just to prove they are legitimate voters.
Some people, like an 87-year-old woman and a man with 80% disability, had to go through a lot of hardship.
The ruling party says this process might stop genuine voters from voting, while the opposition party says it's necessary for a clean voter list.
The Election Commission has also asked some famous people, like actor Deepak Adhikari and cricketer Mohammad Shami, to prove their citizenship.
The Chief Minister, Mamata Banerjee, has criticized the process and plans to go to court against it.
The Election Commission and the BJP say the process is routine and necessary for accurate voter lists.
Vulnerable voters in West Bengal are facing physical and financial hardships to attend SIR hearings.
The second phase of SIR involves hearings for 1.67 crore electors under scrutiny.
Elderly, disabled, and daily wage earners are disproportionately affected, with some traveling long distances and losing wages.
The ruling TMC alleges the SIR risks disenfranchising genuine voters, while the BJP insists it's necessary for transparency.
The Election Commission has summoned celebrities, including actor Deepak Adhikari and cricketer Mohammad Shami, for SIR hearings.
- Who
- Vulnerable voters, including elderly, disabled, and daily wage earners, in West Bengal, along with celebrities like Deepak Adhikari and Mohammad Shami
- What
- Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls causing hardship and controversy
- Where
- Across rural and urban West Bengal
- When
- Second phase of SIR began on December 27, with hearings ongoing
- Why
- To clean up voter lists, but causing disenfranchisement and distress among vulnerable groups, and political tensions
Key facts
- Draft Electorate
- 7.08 crore
- Names Deleted
- 58 lakh
- Electors Under Scrutiny
- 1.67 crore
- Logical Discrepancies
- 1.36 crore
- Missing Mapping Records
- 31 lakh
- Summoned MP
- Deepak Adhikari (Dev)
- Summoned Cricketer
- Mohammad Shami
- Summoned Poet
- Joy Goswami
- Summoned Actor Couple
- Kaushik Banerjee and Laboni Sarkar
- Summoned Actor
- Anirban Bhattacharya
Timeline
Election Commission trials voter list update in Bihar.
Then, it expands nationwide, following success.
Revision announced, sparking political debate.
Process causes voter inconvenience.
Quotes
Navdeep Rinwa
Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) of Uttar Pradesh
“These lists can be found online on ceouttarpradesh.nic.in, or voters.eci.gov.in websites under the ASDDR list (A-‘Absent’, S ‘Shifted’, D ‘Dead’, D ‘Duplicate’ and R as ‘Enumeration Form Refused’).”
indianexpress.com
“The 2.89 crore names are those whom Booth Level Officers (BLOs) could not locate or whose enumeration forms they didn’t receive.”
indianexpress.com
Derek O'Brien's application
An application filed by Trinamool Congress MP Derek O'Brien in the Supreme Court
“The ECI cannot act arbitrarily, capriciously or dehors law, nor can it substitute legally prescribed and set procedures with ad hoc or informal mechanisms.”
m.rediff.com
Sources
Vulnerable Voters Bear Brunt Of Bengal SIR, Travel For Kilometres
ECI seeks action taken report from Bengal DEOs over voter enrolment irregularities
EC summons TMC MP Dev, family for SIR review; party cries harassment of actor-MP - Telegraph India
Shami Gets EC Notice, Misses SIR Hearing for Match
Will move court on Tuesday against inhuman conduct of SIR: Mamata
CM has right to raise concerns over SIR, EC will address them: Bengal Guv
Bengal SIR 2.0: Eminent personalities, including Dev and Mohammad Shami, summoned for hearing by EC
Bengal SIR: Cricketer Mohammad Shami, TMC MP Dev, eminent poet Joy Goswami, others summoned by EC. Here's why
Man found dead in Bengal, family alleges stress over SIR hearing
How to find your name on UP draft electoral roll, what to do if it’s not on the list, how to get it added
TMC files plea in SC over SIR lapses in Bengal
Man found dead in Bengal, family blames stress over SIR
Nizamabad Collector Seeks Accountability from BLOs, AEROs over SIR Delays





