Archive · 11 Dec 2025
44 Judges Defend CJI Surya Kant on Rohingya Remarks
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant made some remarks about illegal Rohingya immigrants during a court hearing.
Some people, like Prashant Bhushan, criticized him, saying his words were unfair.
But 44 former judges wrote a letter supporting the Chief Justice.
They said his questions were about the law and not meant to be prejudiced.
They also said that the Rohingya entered India illegally and cannot just claim to be refugees.
The former judges warned that attacking the judiciary like this could harm its independence.
The debate is about whether the Chief Justice was right to question the legal status of the Rohingya or if his words were unfair.
44 former judges defended CJI Surya Kant's remarks on illegal Rohingya immigrants, calling criticism a motivated attack.
CJI Kant questioned the legal status of Rohingya immigrants during a court hearing on December 2, 2025.
Critics, including Prashant Bhushan, described the CJI's remarks as 'unconscionable' and prejudiced.
The former judges highlighted that the Rohingya entered India illegally and cannot unilaterally claim refugee status.
The debate centers on the legitimacy of the CJI's legal questions versus the criticism of his remarks as prejudiced.
- Who
- Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, 44 former judges, leftist activists led by Prashant Bhushan
- What
- Defense of CJI Surya Kant's remarks on illegal Rohingya immigrants and criticism of those remarks
- When
- December 2, 2025 (remarks), December 5, 2025 (criticism), December 9, 2025 (defense)
- Where
- India
- Why
- To address the legal status and rights of illegal Rohingya immigrants in India
Critics of CJI Surya Kant
Supporters of CJI Surya Kant
Nature of CJI's Remarks
Critics of CJI Surya Kant
The remarks were described as 'unconscionable' and prejudiced against illegal immigrants.
Supporters of CJI Surya Kant
The remarks were a legitimate legal question about the status of illegal immigrants.
Legitimacy of Criticism
Critics of CJI Surya Kant
The criticism was a fair and principled disagreement with the CJI's stance.
Supporters of CJI Surya Kant
The criticism was a motivated attack aimed at delegitimizing the judiciary.
Legal Status of Rohingya
Critics of CJI Surya Kant
The Rohingya should be granted refugee status and human rights.
Supporters of CJI Surya Kant
The Rohingya entered India illegally and cannot unilaterally claim refugee status.
- Date of Open Letter by Former Judges
- December 9, 2025
- Number of Former Judges Supporting CJI
- 44
- Date of CJI's Remarks
- December 2, 2025
- Key Figures Supporting CJI
- Justices Anil Dave and Hemant Gupta
- Key Figures Criticizing CJI
- Prashant Bhushan and CJAR
- Legal Status of Rohingya in India
- Not recognized as refugees by any statutory framework
- India's Position on UN Refugee Convention
- Not a signatory