Archive · 19 Sep 2026
Jadavpur Scholars Warn Faculty Transfer Bill Threatens PhD Research
Jadavpur University researchers are worried about a new West Bengal transfer bill.
The bill would allow staff to move between state-run universities, although reports mainly discuss teaching faculty.
Some teachers supervise students working on PhD degrees.
The researchers say students could lose their supervisors if those teachers are transferred.
They worry this could create problems for PhD registrations and the validity of research work.
Fellowships might also be affected because some require a supervisor’s signature and progress report.
Laboratory experiments and long-term social science projects could become difficult to continue.
The researchers asked Governor R N Ravi to hear their concerns.
The state government has said the transfers could help newer universities by bringing in experienced professors.
Jadavpur University research scholars oppose a West Bengal bill allowing inter-university staff transfers.
JURSA says transferred supervisors could disrupt PhD supervision and raise questions about registration validity.
The scholars warn that fellowships requiring supervisors’ remarks and signatures could be affected.
Laboratory research, long-developed samples, and long-term social science projects may face continuity problems.
JURSA has sought Governor and Chancellor R N Ravi’s intervention through a small delegation.
- Who
- The Jadavpur University Research Scholars Association and research scholars at Jadavpur University, including representatives Arijit Maity and Affreen Begum.
- What
- They oppose or question a West Bengal bill providing for inter-university transfers and warn of disruptions to PhD supervision, fellowships, registrations, and ongoing research.
- When
- The bill was introduced on September 9, passed by the West Bengal Assembly, and is awaiting the governor’s consent; the scholars’ representation was reported as sent on Thursday or Friday.
- Where
- Jadavpur University in Kolkata, West Bengal, and other state-run universities covered by the bill.
- Why
- The scholars say transferred supervisors could create technical, legal, financial, logistical, and mental-health difficulties, while the state government says transfers could strengthen newer universities.
Research scholars’ concerns
State government’s rationale
Effect on universities
Research scholars’ concerns
JURSA says transfers could disrupt PhD supervision, research continuity, fellowships, registrations, and scholars’ well-being.
State government’s rationale
Chief minister Suvendu Adhikari said the government wants to move senior professors from established universities to newer district universities to strengthen their standards.
Supervision rules
Research scholars’ concerns
The scholars cite UGC regulations and argue that a faculty member transferred to another institution may no longer be able to supervise a scholar enrolled at the former institution.
State government’s rationale
The articles do not report a detailed government response to JURSA’s interpretation of the UGC rules.
Research continuity
Research scholars’ concerns
Researchers say laboratory samples, experiments, and long-term social science projects could suffer if supervisors change.
State government’s rationale
The stated government objective is to use experienced professors to support fledgling state universities, though the articles do not specify how research continuity would be protected.
- Organisation
- Jadavpur University Research Scholars Association (JURSA)
- Legislation
- West Bengal Inter-University Transfer Bill, passed by the state Assembly
- Reported scope
- The bill is described as covering teaching faculty in some reports and teaching and non-teaching staff in another
- Regulation cited
- University Grants Commission Minimum Standards and Procedures for Award of PhD Degree Regulations, 2022
- Main concern
- Transferred supervisors may no longer be able to supervise scholars at their former institution
- Fellowship concern
- Some funding schemes require designated supervisors’ remarks and signatures on progress reports
- Requested action
- A meeting with Governor and Chancellor R N Ravi through a small delegation
- Bill status
- Passed by the West Bengal Assembly and awaiting the governor’s consent
Sources
Jadavpur University Scholars Flag PhD, Fellowship Risks Over West Bengal Faculty Transfer Bill, Seek Governor Ravi's Intervention
JU research scholars oppose inter-university faculty transfers, cite research concerns