Politics · Canada · 2 hrs ago
Critics urge more Senate scrutiny of Canada’s lawful-access bill
Critics are urging Canada’s prime minister to slow Bill C-22, a proposed lawful-access bill now being examined by the Senate.
The bill would require electronic service providers to change their systems so police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service can conduct surveillance and monitoring.
It would also let the public safety minister issue secret orders to companies, and could require providers to keep some customer metadata for up to a year.
That metadata could reveal who contacted whom and help pinpoint a person’s location, though it would not include emails, browsing history, social-media activity or text messages.
Lawyers and privacy advocates warn that the bill could face a Charter challenge if passed without further changes, potentially delaying its implementation.
The Senate committee has ended witness testimony and plans to consider amendments next week, while its chair says it will have heard from more than 50 witnesses.
Critics are urging the Prime Minister to extend Senate scrutiny of Bill C-22, saying the legislation is being rushed.
The bill would require electronic service providers to make changes that give police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service surveillance and monitoring capabilities.
It would also allow the Public Safety Minister to issue secret orders to companies operating in Canada.
Experts and organizations have asked the Prime Minister to intervene, while lawyers warn the bill could face a Charter challenge if it is not amended.
The Senate committee chair said the committee would have heard from more than 50 witnesses before it considers the bill clause by clause.
- Who
- Critics, including experts and organizations, are calling for more Senate scrutiny. The Senate National Security Committee is considering the bill.
- What
- Critics say Bill C-22 is being rushed and should be examined further and amended.
- When
- The Senate committee plans to consider amendments next week.
- Where
- Canada.
- Why
- Critics say more time is needed to hear experts and assess the bill’s effects, including possible impacts on privacy and legal challenges.
Bill C-22 critics
Senate National Security Committee
Senate scrutiny
Bill C-22 critics
Critics say the committee should extend its study and hear more experts.
Senate National Security Committee
The committee chair said it would have heard from more than 50 witnesses representing a wide range of views.
Pace of consideration
Bill C-22 critics
Critics say the bill is being rushed through Parliament.
Senate National Security Committee
The committee has opted to speed its passage through committee and move to clause-by-clause consideration.
Experts and organizations, including OpenMedia and Amnesty International, sent the Prime Minister a joint letter asking him to intervene and amend Bill C-22.
Michael Geist gave evidence to the Senate committee.
Geist said he was concerned senators would not be able to fully appreciate the bill’s impact and implications based on the hearings held.
The Senate committee plans to move to consideration of amendments.
- Bill
- C-22
- Witnesses
- More than 50, according to committee chair Marty Deacon
- Metadata retention
- Up to one year
- Organizations signing letter
- OpenMedia and Amnesty International
- Requested extension
- Senate study to the spring
1 source
What people are saying
scratched the surface
really constitutionally vulnerable if it passes in its current form with the sort of structure that the government has laid out
the most consequential legislation for Canadian privacy of our lifetimes
intervene and extend Senate study to the spring