Politics · United Kingdom · 2 hrs ago
Early results of rail nationalisation are mixed
The UK government is bringing passenger rail services into public ownership, and six operators have been nationalised so far.
South Western Railway was taken into public ownership in May 2025, but cancellations increased during its first year.
The government says heat, signal failures and trespass incidents affected performance, while it has also added trains and recruited drivers.
TransPennine Express, nationalised in 2023 under the previous government, has seen cancellations fall after changes to services and staffing.
Its cancellation rate was still above the Great Britain average in the year to August.
Rail performance can also depend on infrastructure, weather and how well a service was running before a takeover.
Major structural changes are still ahead, so experts say it is too early to know whether public ownership will deliver lasting improvements.
Labour is bringing nearly all passenger rail services into public ownership, but early results on reliability are mixed.
South Western Railway was nationalised in May 2025 and saw cancellations increase during its first year in public hands.
The government says high temperatures, signal failures and trespass incidents affected SWR’s performance.
TransPennine Express, nationalised in May 2023, reduced cancellations, but its rate remained above the Great Britain average in the year to August.
Experts say it is too early to judge the impact because rail performance depends on many factors and major structural changes have yet to be introduced.
- Who
- The UK government is bringing passenger rail services into public ownership. Rail passengers and train operators are affected.
- What
- Early results of rail nationalisation show mixed reliability outcomes.
- When
- Labour’s programme is under way; SWR was nationalised in May 2025 and TransPennine Express in May 2023.
- Where
- Great Britain, including services run by South Western Railway and TransPennine Express.
- Why
- The government is bringing nearly all passenger rail services into public hands. The story examines whether this will improve reliability.
Conservatives
UK government
SWR’s performance
Conservatives
The Conservatives cite SWR as an example that public control does not necessarily improve services or fix key problems.
UK government
The government says SWR’s early period in public hands was affected by high temperatures, signal failures and trespass incidents.
TransPennine Express was nationalised under the Conservative government.
South Western Railway was nationalised, becoming the first of six services brought into public ownership under Labour so far.
A power failure affecting Network Rail’s operating centre in Manchester halted trains across north-west England shortly before 14:00.
- Public support
- Almost two thirds, according to a YouGov tracker poll
- SWR nationalisation
- May 2025
- TransPennine Express nationalisation
- May 2023
- Services brought into public ownership under Labour
- Six so far
- Power failure
- Shortly before 14:00 on 6 August; affected Network Rail’s operating centre in Manchester
What people are saying
I think the phrase 'emperor's new clothes' comes to mind… it's still unreliable.
Sources
Related news
IMF downgrades UK growth outlook and warns Labour against unaffordable support
Farage pledges five-year suspension of UK asylum system
Burnham reopens debate over Britain’s relationship with the EU
Ministers plan cuts to heat pump grants to help fund defence spending
Burnham says Russia interfered in 2016 Brexit vote
Swinney says pension claims issue is closed after advisers decline inquiry
Andy Burnham says he did not claim Russia influenced the Brexit vote
Burnham says he has no evidence Russia influenced the Brexit vote
Emails show Derbyshire council tracked son amid dispute over his mother's gate
UK spent £1.1 trillion more on working-age welfare than infrastructure
UK to review security for public figures after Ann Widdecombe’s killing
