World · Europe · 2 hrs ago
Italian surgeon says France gave him room to lead a thoracic surgery unit
Antonio Minniti left Italy for France in 1998 while training in thoracic surgery at the University of Messina.
He had been offered a year of training in Bordeaux, where he expected to learn a technique and return to Italy to develop it.
Instead, he stayed in France and eventually moved from Bordeaux to Pau.
In Pau, he founded and led a thoracic surgery unit, a role he says he has held for 20 years.
Minniti says he left because he could not find room to advance in Italy, where trainees were expected to take on many different jobs.
He praises the French system for recognising ability, but says foreign doctors must keep proving themselves to earn responsibility.
His story highlights the different opportunities and pressures facing doctors who move abroad.
Antonio Minniti says he left Italy because he could not find room to advance and went on to lead a thoracic surgery unit in France.
He moved from Messina to Pau to establish the unit, after training in Bordeaux.
Minniti says France offered him professional opportunities but that, as a foreigner, he had to prove himself continually to gain responsibility.
He says his training in Italy involved heavy duties and unpaid work assisting in operations across several specialties.
- Who
- Antonio Minniti, an Italian thoracic surgeon from Reggio Calabria.
- What
- He moved to France and established and led a thoracic surgery unit.
- When
- He says he arrived in France on 21 October 1998.
- Where
- He moved from Messina to Pau after a period of training in Bordeaux.
- Why
- He says he could not find room to advance in Italy and wanted to gain experience in a higher-volume thoracic surgery centre.
This story does not have two clearly opposing sides.
Minniti says he decided to leave the University of Messina while in the third year of a five-year thoracic surgery specialization.
He went to Bordeaux under an inter-university agreement to learn a surgical technique and planned to return to Messina.
Minniti says he arrived in France and has lived there ever since.
After a difficult start and a short holiday in Calabria, he returned to Bordeaux happy to continue his experience.
- Arrival in France
- 21 October 1998
- Training city
- Bordeaux
- Move from Italy
- Messina to Pau
- Specialization
- Third year of a five-year thoracic surgery program
- Bordeaux unit
- 60 beds and four operating rooms for thoracic surgery
What people are saying
France offers great opportunities, but gives nothing away.
You have to constantly prove that you are worth more than your colleagues to obtain positions of responsibility.
I feel perfectly defined by the role of brain drain, because I found no room in Italy.
We should copy the seriousness and division of roles from the French.