Business · Companies · 7 hrs ago
Coles challenges Australia’s block on a second Kalgoorlie supermarket
Coles is challenging a decision to block its planned supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder, a city about 600 kilometres east of Perth.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission stopped the project in July, using new powers under Australia’s merger laws.
The watchdog says the new store could weaken competition by taking business from smaller independent rivals, especially O’Connor Fresh IGA, which is about two kilometres from the proposed site.
IGA has argued that losing customers could put its business at risk, while Coles says blocking its expansion could discourage investment in the city.
The dispute concerns a market with six existing supermarkets, including one Coles store, and follows the arrival of a Spudshed supermarket last year.
The Australian Competition Tribunal has completed eight days of hearings in Melbourne, but no decision is given yet.
The tribunal’s decision will determine whether Coles can proceed with its proposed second store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
The Australian Competition Tribunal has heard Coles’ appeal against a decision blocking a second supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
The ACCC blocked the proposed development in July, citing the risk that it could weaken competition and harm smaller independent businesses.
Coles argues the decision could discourage investment in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
The tribunal held eight days of hearings in Melbourne’s Federal Court, which wrapped this week.
The appeal is described as a test case for Australia’s new merger laws.
- Who
- Coles is appealing the decision. The ACCC blocked the development, and O'Connor Fresh IGA is a nearby competitor.
- What
- Coles is challenging the block on a proposed second supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
- When
- The ACCC blocked the development in July. The tribunal hearings wrapped this week.
- Where
- Kalgoorlie-Boulder, about 600km east of Perth; the hearings were held in Melbourne’s Federal Court.
- Why
- The ACCC cited the potential harm to competition and smaller independent competitors. Coles says the intervention could have a chilling effect on investment.
Coles
ACCC and O'Connor Fresh IGA
Competition
Coles
Coles argues the proposed development should be allowed.
ACCC and O'Connor Fresh IGA
The ACCC says it could substantially lessen competition; O'Connor Fresh IGA says there is a commercially real possibility it would go out of business.
Investment and consumer choice
Coles
Coles says blocking the development could have a chilling effect on investment.
ACCC and O'Connor Fresh IGA
The Kalgoorlie-Boulder Chamber of Commerce and Industry says the expansion is not necessary or justified and would not meaningfully increase consumer choice.
The ACCC used its new powers to block Coles from building a supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
Coles appealed the ACCC’s decision.
The Australian Competition Tribunal wrapped eight days of hearings in Melbourne’s Federal Court.
- Proposed development
- Second Coles supermarket and a liquor store
- Location
- Kalgoorlie-Boulder, about 600km east of Perth
- Existing supermarkets
- Six in Kalgoorlie-Boulder, including one Coles in the CBD
- Nearest competitor
- O'Connor Fresh IGA, about 2km from the proposed development
- Hearing duration
- Eight days
What people are saying
Fundamentally, it's appalling that a group of faceless, anonymous people on the other side of Australia get involved in free enterprise here.
The ACCC's view was it offers consumers a differentiated product in terms of range and service
Coles' own business case … without getting into the confidential figures … identifies a proportion of Coles' business from the new supermarket will come from the business that's currently being done by O'Connor Fresh IGA.