Health · Healthcare & Policy · 2 hrs ago
Researchers say tobacco companies use complaints and threats to silence critics
Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary complained about researcher Charlotta Pisinger after she criticised heated tobacco products and vapes in media interviews.
A paper led by Australian physician Emily Banks, published in the journal Tobacco Control, says complaints to researchers’ employers are part of a wider pattern.
It describes tactics including online abuse, legal threats and requests for information that can burden or discredit tobacco-control advocates.
Australian researcher Raglan Maddox said he faced intense abuse after speaking about children’s nicotine addiction during a vaping inquiry.
The paper says intimidation can silence critics and weaken tobacco regulation, though it notes that industry involvement cannot be confirmed in every case.
It urges governments and employers to treat intimidation as a workplace safety issue and offers practical ways for researchers to prepare for and respond to pushback.
Researchers say tobacco companies use complaints, legal threats and other tactics to intimidate critics and weaken tobacco regulation.
A report in the journal Tobacco Control describes complaints to employers of tobacco-control advocates as part of a systemic challenge.
The report was led by Australian physician and epidemiologist Prof Emily Banks.
Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary complained to the University of Southern Denmark about Prof Charlotta Pisinger’s media comments on heated tobacco and vapes.
The researchers call on governments and employers to treat intimidation as an occupational health and safety issue.
- Who
- Tobacco-control researchers and advocates, including Prof Emily Banks and Prof Charlotta Pisinger, say they face intimidation. Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary filed a complaint about Pisinger.
- What
- Researchers say tobacco companies use complaints and threats, among other tactics, to silence critics and weaken regulation.
- When
- The report was published on a Thursday. The article was published on 19 November 2026.
- Where
- The complaint was made to the University of Southern Denmark. The report appeared in the journal Tobacco Control.
- Why
- The researchers say these tactics are used to push back against advocates, researchers and policymakers and to weaken regulation.
Tobacco-control researchers
Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary
Complaints
Tobacco-control researchers
Researchers say complaints to employers are part of a systemic effort to intimidate and silence critics.
Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary
PMI’s complaint said Pisinger breached the university’s research communication standards.
Pisinger’s comments
Tobacco-control researchers
The researchers describe her media appearances as questioning the safety of heated tobacco and vapes.
Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary
PMI accused her of overstating conclusions, omitting context and failing to clarify whether her comments were expert opinion or personal opinion.
Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary filed a complaint with Pisinger’s employer about her media comments.
A report led by Prof Emily Banks was published in the journal Tobacco Control.
- Report journal
- Tobacco Control
- Report lead
- Prof Emily Banks
- Complaint filer
- Philip Morris International’s Danish subsidiary
- Complaint recipient
- University of Southern Denmark
- Article publication date
- 19 November 2026
What people are saying
Of course people have the right to seek information, but our paper finds that freedom of information requests can be weaponised for industry intimidation.
The abuse I copped for 24 hours after that was phenomenal.
Pisinger claims that PMI lies and deceives. We assume that Pisinger’s statements are to be understood polemically and not as an expression of a factual legal matter.
In countries where proper tobacco legislation is still not in place, they [the tobacco industry] still charge ahead and do everything they can to promote cigarettes.