World · North America · 2 hrs ago
Canada’s top court will let some intervenors argue in person
The Supreme Court of Canada will reopen in-person arguments to some intervenors starting in April 2027.
Intervenors are groups or governments that are not direct parties to a case but offer views on its issues.
Since the court resumed in-person hearings in 2022, intervenors have been limited to appearing by Zoom, a rule that lawyers said made their arguments less effective.
The court had defended virtual appearances as a way to make participation less expensive and said all submissions receive equal consideration.
Under a new pilot project, intervenors can argue in person or by Zoom.
In-person appearances will need court approval, and intervenors generally have five minutes to speak.
The court says it will also consider whether interventions unduly imbalance the arguments in a case.
The Supreme Court of Canada will allow some intervenors to present arguments in person starting in April 2027.
The change is a pilot project that also retains the option of appearing by Zoom.
In-person appearances will require the court’s approval, and intervenors generally receive five minutes to speak.
Lawyers had criticized the Zoom-only policy, saying virtual appearances muted the impact of intervenors’ oral arguments.
The court says submissions made in writing, in person or on Zoom receive equal consideration.
- Who
- The Supreme Court of Canada will allow some intervenors to appear in person.
- What
- It is launching a pilot project allowing intervenors to present arguments in person or on Zoom. In-person appearances require court approval.
- When
- The pilot project begins in April 2027.
- Where
- The Supreme Court of Canada.
- Why
- The court says the change will provide greater flexibility and let it assess and refine its practices.
Lawyers and intervenors
Supreme Court of Canada
Oral participation
Lawyers and intervenors
Lawyers and intervenors objected to limiting intervenors to Zoom, saying virtual appearances muted the impact of their arguments.
Supreme Court of Canada
The court has said the system improved access to justice by making participation less expensive.
In-person appearances
Lawyers and intervenors
Lawyers and intervenors supported reopening the option for in-person arguments.
Supreme Court of Canada
The court will allow in-person appearances only with its approval.
The court allowed all parties to appear in person.
The courtroom reopened for in-person hearings, but intervenors remained on Zoom.
Attorneys-general sought a one-time exception to the Zoom-only rule ahead of the Bill 21 hearing.
The Supreme Court rejected the requests for exceptions.
The pilot project allowing some intervenors to argue in person is due to begin.
- Start date
- April 2027
- Format
- In-person or Zoom, subject to court approval for in-person appearances
- Speaking time
- Intervenors generally get five minutes
- Past policy
- Intervenors remained on Zoom after in-person hearings resumed in 2022
- Bill 21 hearing
- Four days
- Intervenors at Bill 21 hearing
- 38 outside intervenors and six attorneys-general
What people are saying
are given equal consideration
We have raised concerns about limiting intervenors to virtual participation, and we appreciate the Court’s openness to our members’ views,
As a pilot project, this initiative will allow the court to continue assessing and refining its practices to ensure they best serve the public interest,