Politics · Germany · 16 hrs ago
German defence minister apologises for calling US official's view 'stupid'
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius apologised to US defence official Elbridge Colby for calling his view on Ukrainian strikes “stupid.”
Pistorius said he had used an inappropriate phrase during a public exchange in Brussels and had called Colby to apologise.
The two still disagree over Ukraine's long-range strikes inside Russia: Colby argues they have not helped end the war or slow Russian advances.
Pistorius says it is wrong to criticise Ukrainian strikes without also condemning Russia’s attacks on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating systems.
Germany supports developing and producing long-range weapons for Ukraine, while Pistorius says Ukraine decides how to use them.
He said he does not expect the disagreement to harm German-US defence cooperation.
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius apologised for calling US official Elbridge Colby’s criticism of Ukrainian strikes into Russia “stupid.”
Pistorius said he regretted his choice of words but maintained that he and Colby held different views.
Colby has argued that Ukrainian deep strikes have not helped end the war or slow Russian advances.
Pistorius said the strikes should be considered alongside Russian attacks on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating infrastructure.
The disagreement followed a meeting of Ukraine’s military backers in Brussels.
- Who
- German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius and US Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby.
- What
- Pistorius apologised for calling Colby’s opposition to Ukrainian deep strikes into Russia “stupid.” He said he would not withdraw his criticism.
- When
- Pistorius said on Friday that he had apologised in a call on Wednesday.
- Where
- The disagreement surfaced at a meeting in Brussels of Ukraine’s military backers.
- Why
- Colby questioned whether Ukrainian long-range strikes into Russia were effective; Pistorius objected to that criticism.
Boris Pistorius
Elbridge Colby
Effect of Ukrainian strikes
Boris Pistorius
Pistorius defended the strikes as targeted and strategic, and said they were not aimed at civilians.
Elbridge Colby
Colby said the strikes had not helped end the war or blunt Russia’s advances on the front line.
Response to Russian attacks
Boris Pistorius
Pistorius said criticism of Ukrainian strikes should also address Russian attacks on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating infrastructure.
Elbridge Colby
Colby’s stated assessment focused on the effectiveness of Ukrainian strikes.
Colby questioned Ukrainian deep strikes at a meeting of Ukraine’s military backers in Brussels.
Pistorius called Colby to apologise for his choice of words and discuss their differing views.
Pistorius said in an interview that his wording was inappropriate but that he stood by his criticism.
- German defence minister
- Boris Pistorius
- US official
- Elbridge Colby, Pentagon policy chief
- Meeting location
- NATO alliance headquarters in Brussels
- Call
- Pistorius said he spoke with Colby on Wednesday
- Disputed issue
- Ukraine’s long-range strikes into Russia
4 sources
What people are saying
I apologised for my choice of words, but I also made it clear – and he sees it the same way – that we simply have different views on the matter.
Das hätte ich nicht tun sollen.
our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line