Politics · United Kingdom · 7 hrs ago
Letter argues food aid should not replace incomes that let people buy food
Jane Middleton argues that food waste and food insecurity in Britain are separate problems.
She says giving surplus food to people in poverty may create a two-tier system in which they have less choice and dignity.
The letter responds to a proposal to redistribute surplus food to address hunger.
Middleton says food aid can help in the short term, but relying on it may entrench poverty and reduce pressure on large companies to cut waste.
She argues that the right to food includes having enough income to buy food through ordinary, socially accepted means.
She suggests surplus food could instead be arranged for schools, hospitals and prisons.
Her central point is that people should not have to rely on charity to eat.
Jane Middleton argues that food-waste redistribution should not be used to address domestic food insecurity.
She says relying on charity denies people in poverty the dignity of choosing their own food.
Middleton argues that food aid can entrench poverty and reduce pressure on large companies to tackle food waste.
She says people should have enough income to buy food through socially acceptable means.
The letter suggests surplus food could instead go to schools, hospitals and prisons.
- Who
- Jane Middleton wrote the letter, responding to Charlotte Hill.
- What
- Middleton argues that food aid should not replace incomes that allow people to buy food.
- When
- The letter was published on 11 October 2026.
- Where
- The letter refers to the United Kingdom.
- Why
- Middleton says relying on charity denies people choice and can entrench poverty.
Charlotte Hill
Jane Middleton
Role of food redistribution
Charlotte Hill
Hill suggests using surplus food to address food insecurity.
Jane Middleton
Middleton says this conflates food waste with domestic food insecurity.
Effect on people in poverty
Charlotte Hill
Hill’s cited position supports redistribution of unavoidable surplus food.
Jane Middleton
Middleton says charity-based food aid denies people choice and entrenches poverty.
The question we should be asking is not how can we use up surplus food, but how we can ensure that no one has to rely on charity in order to eat.
In a country with food surpluses, we should be battling against the institutionalisation of food aid, not encouraging it.
Charlotte Hill’s article, cited by Middleton, argued for a redistribution revolution.
Jane Middleton’s letter was published in the Guardian.
- Letter writer
- Jane Middleton
- Respondent
- Charlotte Hill
- Publication date
- 11 October 2026
- Referenced article date
- 6 October
- Suggested recipients of surplus food
- Schools, hospitals and prisons










